My feminist take on Palomar

So…

I’m in love.
With the town of Palomar.
How could you not? You’d have to have a heart of stone not to fall in love with Hernandez’s creations. The characters are so warm, and lifelike, that even the ones that are supposed to be annoying (like Tonantzin and Toco) are just so loveable, you can’t help but sigh and say, “Oh you!” under your breath, even though you don’t even really know the character too well yet!
This may be due to the fact that every character kind of gets their say. One character isn’t really favoured over the other when it comes to hearing their side of the story. Having multiple story angles shows how Gilbert is such an intelligent story teller, fore the more his readers love all his characters, the more involved they will be in the story of Palomar.
I’ve always been a sucker for character development in stories. I think that knowing the psychology behind why someone does what they do motivates me to become involved in the story futhur. It also becomes more true to life if characters are multi dimensional, because, lets face it, most people in the real world are mostly f***ed up!
I know everyone goes on about Luba, who, if you had to pick a ‘main’ character, she would be it. I say this because even when she’s not involved directly in a characters story, she is always mentioned. Mainly by one of the men who has slept/wants to sleep with her, or one of the women who basically all want to pop her giant breasts like balloons. I’m not that fussed about her actually, I’m more into the characters that you don’t see that often. Like, Toco -

I like him because he’s so crass, and crazy. He speaks his mind, and I don’t know why, but I find him quite endearing. Hes’ cute and weird and doesn’t give a f what anyone thinks. My kinda’ guy really!

Here’s a few more photos that I took from “Heartbreak soup”  of my mate Toco.

Isn’t he just adorable?! How funny is he?! Look at those floppy sleeves! I mean, what a great character trait! You may not be able to appreciate him without a consistent flow of panels, but, trust me – he is a pretty special character.

Heraclio and Carmen - how cute is this?!

Probably the next character that I really dig is Heraclio. It’s funny, because I love him for exactly the opposite reasons I love Toco. He’s a good honest guy, the kind you dream of marrying when you’re a little girl. He’s also a man of the arts, which seems to be a rarity in Palomar. I guess it’s because he did spend some years away from the town and at college (or University as we call it in Oz) so he brings his knowledge of the outside world into his community. This doesn’t mean that people appreciate it though, and he is laughed at for just being a music teacher and not something more manly. The story that made me love him was, “For the love of Carmen” in which he talks about his utter devotion to his wife.
 The story doesn’t only talk about his relationship with her, but with Luba, who seduced him when he was a teenager. Instead of making him into a randy teen hound, it instead depresses him, and Hernandez deals with another side to teen sex – confusion and anguish. It shows how much Hernandez strays from ‘stereotypical’ characters. He really does delve into the psyche of his brood, and treats them like ‘real’ people, rather than just drawings on a page. Each character has their on unique personality, and such big personalities at that!! Everyone from the old to the young are bursting with energy and adventure for the world around them. Actually, there must be something in the water in Palomar, as all the characters are pretty quirky and full-on…and that’s why I love it so much!

Luba

Going back to Luba, though everyone goes on and on about her being “one of the best American comic book characters ever created” (I read that quote in the New York Times, or the Times, or something like that…I just can’t remember which one!) I think she’s actually the least exciting character in “Heartbreak soup” – I mean, she’s just a slutty busty chick with heaps of kids and a fear of commitment! I’m pretty sure something must occur for her to get more interesting, but for now, I find the other women in Palomar much more exciting.

Carmen

Take Carmen for instance, a girl who was found in a market in a sack with ‘Good riddance’ written on it when she was a baby. As a kid she had a filthy potty mouth, and ended up being an adult with a cruel streak, but a sensitive one at that. She’s so tiny, she looks like a dwarf, but of course, she’s incredibly fiesty, but you can tell, and I say this by also now have read halfway through “Human Diastrophism” (which is the second in the three Palomar books) that she does have a big heart, and does care muchly for those who she loves.

Chelo

Or Chelo – she’s such a strong woman who has enforced the “no girl over 18 must wear their skirt above their knees” rule so that, she says, the women in Palomar won’t just be seen like objects of desire by the towns men. She wants them to have some dignity. It’s funny because, at the books start, you believe that Chelo is actually going to be the star of the show. The first panels show a picture of her (and the next, of Vincent), and reads

“As well as giving you baths for a living in those days, Chelo was also a midwife. She can tell you stories.
It was Chelo who talked Vincent’s mother Gabriela into not drowning him when he was but a few minutes into our grey world.”

When Luba enters the town, she takes away Chelo’s bathing customers and starts up her own bath house. Though in the end, it’s best for Chelo as she becomes the sheriff and all, but initially, Luba is a threat to her alpha female status, as she is younger, and has a more female figure (whilst Chelo is quite buff) – which of course is more desirable to the male customer!

Tonantzin

Then there’s Tonantzin, who is also a slut, actually, I think she doesn’t have a rule as to which men she does and doesn’t sleep with! But she’s fun and kind of ditzy, and doesn’t take herself too seriously…well, untill she gets all caught up in the political rantings of a jailbird…but that’s another story altogether!

 The other female character that really stands out, in a feminist point of view, is Ofelia. She has health problems, but even she can look after Luba’s children better than Luba can. (I think I may have to do a post on all the things I disagree about Luba! Well, that is if she doesn’t change into a respectable female characters sometime within the next few books!) She cares for them, and dearly loves them. When something bad happens to them, she is obviously destressed, whereas Luba doesn’t seem to care that much.

Ofelia

Well, there you have it! This blog post kind of went into more of a feminist take on the female characters in “Heartbreak Soup”, but being a feminist, I guess I can’t help that! I plan to do another post soon on -
*Why I don’t like Luba
*The men of Palomar
*A review of Human Diastrophism
…oh, and the promised one on Chris Ware…
I know I’ve been crap at posting lately, but moving into a new home has been more work then I originally thought! We’re nearly there though, so hopefully I’ll be able to post more regulary from now on!

**Disclaimer – Just to let you know, all the images in which I have put in here myself are copyrighted. Hernandez, Gilbert, “Heartbreak Soup A love and rockets book”, Fantagraphics Books, Seattle WA, 2007 **

6 Comments (+add yours?)

  1. Ruby_Alexandrine
    Mar 06, 2011 @ 17:11:48

    Heartbreak Soup is amazing and gets better when you read Human Diastrophism.

    With Luba, I think you may have some appreciation for her when you read the Heartbreak Soup and Human Diastrophism’s sequel, Luba (Omnibus). Also you must read Beyond Palomar and read the story Poison River where it goes in depth about Luba’s past and her mother. Luba is a complex character and there is a means to her behavior which I hope you will find out soon when you read more Palomar tales.

    You may want to hold off on the post “Why I don’t like Luba” until you read all of the tales pertaining to Palomar. Other than that, I liked your review. ^_^

    Reply

  2. lmp784
    Mar 07, 2011 @ 00:14:43

    Thanks for the feedback!
    I’m currently near the end of Human Diastrophism, and will hopefully be reviewing it not too soon after I finish (just so it’s fresh in my head n’ all!) – I adore the world of Palomar, and I guess my big thing with Luba is the way in which she goes around ‘seducing’ everyone in her sights. It’s kind of gross, especially when the men in question are usually boys, and she pretty much rapes Humberto. Then there’s the scene in which she goes around with her little kids and hands them over to the fathers and says “This is your father” – which could be the main reason why her kids all escape to America!
    But, with your recommendation, I shall hold off as long as possible with the whole “Why I don’t like Luba” post.
    Thank you so much for replying to my post, and I’m so so glad that you enjoyed my review! It really does mean a lot to me!

    Reply

  3. Ruby_Alexandrine
    Mar 07, 2011 @ 01:21:38

    You’re welcome! I understand why you dislike Luba for her behavior in both books. When you get to read the Luba omnibus, the storytelling gets even better and more complex.

    If you wrote the post about disliking Luba after reading Heartbreak Soup and Human Diastrophism, I feel that it would be too soon.

    Reply

  4. lmp784
    Mar 07, 2011 @ 02:40:51

    Ok – deal – I will hold off on my dislike of Luba untill I read the big fat book in my bookshelf with ‘Luba’ on the side of it – I can hold myself back for that long at least!!Cheers for the advice! Can’t wait to get more involved in the storys…man they’re awesome!
    Cheers again!
    Lisa.

    Reply

  5. Ruby_Alexandrine
    Mar 07, 2011 @ 05:12:31

    I’m glad that you show enthusiasm for Gilbert’s work. Before I forget, the Luba omnibus is raunchy and contains a lot of nudity much more than Heartbreak Soup and Human Diastrophism combined. There is plot in between the explicitness yet if you’re going to review it from a feminist point of view, then proceed with caution. Take care!

    Reply

    • lmp784
      Mar 07, 2011 @ 12:44:38

      I don’t mind raunchy storylines, as long as there isn’t any rape or molestation I’m perfectly ok with it – I aint’ no prude!! It’s just when it’s depicted as forced that I get grossed out by it.
      Cheers for the heads up though!

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

%d bloggers like this: